When is RAID not RAID?
Posted in Storage Interconnects & RAID, Advisor - Joe by Joe DisherThere are other posts from my fellow Storage Advisors that go into the gory details of RAID, its importance, and the varying levels of RAID available to customers today. This post is far less technical than that and more literal. To that I ask: When is RAID not RAID?
Let’s first start out by examining the acronym “RAID”. Since RAID stands for “Redundant Array of Independent Disks” you’d think that all RAID levels are “Redundant”, right? Wrong! RAID level 0 (zero) has no redundancy at all. In fact RAID 0, although having the RAID characteristic of stripping data across all disks, does not maintain any redundancy or parity of data.
With this epiphany I decided to examine this a bit closer. If I break down RAID 0 literally I think we may find the answer to this mysterious use of the term RAID 0. I think we can all generally agree that the number 0 (zero) in mathematical terms usually refers to nothing. If I have zero dollars, I don’t have any money at all. So with that I make the most simplistic conjecture that RAID 0, although not redundant is accurate! How is that you say? Well, (using the zero money statement above as a guide) if I have zero RAID, then I don’t have any RAID at all… right?
So there you have it. Although misleading due to the “R” part of RAID, I think I’ve successfully rationalized my way to satisfaction – at least when it comes to RAID 0. When is RAID not RAID? When it’s RAID 0! Or did I decide that it was RAID? Oh well – until next time.
Joe
October 20th, 2005 at 9:17 am
Hi Joe,
Not only is the ‘R’ a misnomer, so is the ‘I’ isn’t it? Originally it stood for ‘inexpensive’ - so when did that change? I guess no-one calls fiberchannel or SCSI disks inexpensive. So you take the ‘R’ out because it’s a lie, and you take the ‘I’ out because it’s a lie too - what are you left with? Just an AD! So what are you really selling???
Bryn Thomas
October 20th, 2005 at 1:52 pm
Bryn - you are absolutely right! How could I have missed that one!
Maybe we can just use the term “Some Array of Disks” or “SAD” for short.
Joe